I can't believe we are even at the point to be considering middle school. I wish 6th grade were part of elementary school like it is in so many other places. But, so it goes....
We are working through several options. The first of these is our districted middle school, which is an okay school. The talk amongst the parents is basically that if your child is in the higher level classes, it's great. That was true of my public middle school too, which has near identical demographics. And yes my GT classes were wonderful.... the problem came in that that you had specials with mixed groups and you still had to deal with riff raff in the hallways. The things I saw and heard in my first year in public school (8th grade) were pretty awful. There were fights in the hallways sometimes. There were people you knew not to make eye contact with. There were 7th graders in my French class who talked about having sex. There were kids in my general music class (which I was in because I came in too late to join chorus) who outright challenged the teacher. There were days I had no one to eat lunch with and I was always anxious about where I'd sit and if I'd have anyone to sit with.
Ben would go into that school in a better position than I did. Many of his friends will be going there, so he will know PLENTY of people and likely never have the lunchtime situation I did. But I know him well enough to know that the hallway dynamics and other things he will see and hear and possibly deal with will not sit well with him. I envision his anxiety coming back full force. He is already very worried about the transition to middle school as it is.
Option 2 is the other public middle school, which scores significantly better and has a much better all-around reputation. He has friends going there as well, less, but plenty. So I wouldn't feel like I was separating him from everyone he knows. Problem is that it's not a sure thing whether he could get in. It would have to be via special permission transfer, which might work, might not. And also, we won't know for sure until JUNE of next year. (Hence why we are also exploring options 3 and 4.) My gut tells me though this is the answer and the fit we are looking for.
Option 3 is a private school that is absolutely perfect convenience-wise. It's five minutes away and the schedule works wonderfully with our current drop off / pick up schedule. We visited and were blown away. Ben probably would have stayed for the day if we had let him. There was LOTS I liked about this school in spite of myself. (didn't want to like it because it has a bit of a reputation for parents with snooty attitudes) I could see where Ben could thrive there and part of me wished we had pursued it before we became entrenched in his current school. No way would I move him out of JES at this point.... but if we had never started there.... maybe it would have been a possibility. But, as much as we all liked the school, there are things that are not so great -- 1) it only goes to 8th grade, so another transition would be coming three years from now... and not like the one from public middle to public high... where friends go with you. It would be all new kids all over again. 2) It's $$.... but we'd be willing to sacrifice to send him there if it were a perfect fit 3) I'm not sure I want to step into that realm of private school parents. Most of them are not my people and I'd feel out of place a lot, I think. Again, would sacrifice my own social comfort if it were a good fit.... but my gut tells me the fit is the other public school.
Option 4: Private school that goes 6-12th. This one is such a longshot. First and foremost, it would mean Ben would be on a shuttle for an hour every morning and every afternoon. He wouldn't get home until after the little guys. AND I'd have to go right from picking them up all the way into Owings Mills (via Hunt Valley) to pick him up from the shuttle stop. That seems like too much of a stretch right now. Maybe high school.... but right now, that just doesn't feel like something we need to be doing.
Like I said, my gut thinks Option 2. I just hope it works out.... just not sure where to go from here. It's a really tough decision. Plus, we also have to consider Simon coming up behind him.... (Jonathan too, but Simon more immediately....) What's a good fit for Ben may not be a good fit for Simon at all. Also, I'm positive if we had to make our districted middle school work for Ben, we could.... it wouldn't be ideal, but it would be doable. Simon would absolutely, positively, be lost lost lost there. NO way can he go there.... not a chance.
UGH. Parenting is HARD.